The ultimate goal of using a computerized maintenance management system is to increase maintenance productivity. Software, like a cmms, also makes it easier for people to do, measure. Optimizing the performance of people and assets is crucial to maintenance success. Measuring productivity in service industries the growth of the service economy presents special challenges for productivity analysts. Metrics and tools for measuring construction productivity. Productivity growth is frequently lauded by the business community, media commentators and politicians as the solution to improving living standards, yet there is little agreement on what productivity actually is. My claim is that it is possible to write grand programs. Then, those values can be compared against each other. Working software is the primary measure of progress.
Although the term productivity is widely used, the difficulty of defining it leads to serious problems in productivity measurement. Factors affecting software maintenance productivity. Analyzing and improving productivity with computerized questionnaires and delay surveys. Measuring maintenance workforce productivity made simple. We then introduce our methodology, followed by an analysis of the data, and, finally, lessons learned and future work. Through personal involvement at all levels of the work process, he has gained vast experience including conducting workforce productivity sampling during daily maintenance and turnaround projects. One standard fpbased measure of supportmaintenance productivity is the number of ftes needed annually to support 10,000 function points in the production environment. Workmeter offers organisations an objective system that enables them to establish continuous improvement in work performance. It also allows you to create processes, like automated reports, that lead to better decisionmaking. Indeed, the investment of time, human resources, and financial considerations associated with implementing cmms software is significant, so its only reasonable to expect returns in the form of increased efficiency to a certain degree, the mechanics of measuring and reporting. Workmeter is a productivity software that delivers objective data so employees can evaluate their own performance, better manage their time and view structural changes positively. The isbsg maintenance and support repository isbsg has a repository of maintenance and support data consisting of metrics for more than 1,100 applications.
By jose baptista, development manager for reliability at quant. Productivity measurement, the potential addedvalue, the actual addedvalue, and. However, there are many different approaches to productivity measurement and. In between, it could go through testing, qa, and staging, depending on your organization. Identification and elimination of barriers to productivity can significantly increase the valueadded contribution of existing maintenance resources. Nov 23, 2016 metrics are essential to a healthy business.
Measuring productivity oecd manual measurement of aggregate and industrylevel productivity growth measures of productivity growth constitute core indicators for the analysis of economic growth. Maintenance measurements are a part of a global set of indicators that gauge your facilities viability. First the differences between software maintenance activities and is development projects are described. How to begin measuring maintenance effectiveness part iii ep editorial staff november 1, 2009 you have a battery of kpis to use in revealing your maintenance reality, including some that can show how well your team is performing. Empirical measurement of technical debt in software systems. Such a measure can be found in the maintenance productivity factor mpf family of metrics. It gives you an idea of individual and team efficiency and productivity. Workmeter is a software solution that enables companies to measure employee productivity. Introduction donald knuth has established an ideal for software developers with the following state ment knuti3. The software is part of trimbles portfolio of connected site survey solutions. Those who have ignored it are no longer competitive or possibly no longer in existence.
In agreement with daskalantonakis, we can found the best motivation to measurement it is finding a numerical value for some software product attributes. So, it is important to ensure that we measure these right sets of information. Surveying or land surveying software assists in the process of evaluating a 3d landscape to determine the angles and distances between a series of points. Mark the increased importance of service industries over the.
Productivity productivity is the ratio between output and input. Survey software to improve productivity gim international. In general, productivity is considered to be the ratio of outputs to inputs of a system. It started as a software project for performance measurement for telecommuting employees working remotely. The questionnaire and delay survey process can be a motivating experience for the participants. Measuring the performance of a software maintenance department. Nevertheless, we will give you some guidelines and tips which will help you to assess, and improve, the productivity of your maintenance function. Measure onboarding effectiveness with employee timeto. Productivity is one of the major determinants of the standard of living, since increases in productivity may result in higher real income and promote price stability. Siemens and topcon offer benefits for asset maintenance mike woof writes. Annals of software engineering 11995122 software complexity and software maintenance. Apr 18, 2017 the best metrics for measuring software development productivity and efficiency are committodeploy time cdt. Not how many, as there will always be some bugs, but rather how much time youre spending.
The maintenance productivity factor plant services. It is interesting to note that the annual survey of. Software productivity measurement proceedings of the may. The top 8 methods for accurately measuring employee. The second goal is to integrate the quality and productivity dimensions of software measurement.
Frequent productivity measurement throughout the life of a project gives management a method to document productivity problems and take corrective actions to minimize damages caused by delay claims. Measures of productivity and their uses measurement of productivity is it a ratio between input and output. The importance of job productivity is clear to all organizations. Ensuring productivity in the workplace can be challenging. The measurement of productivity is an important element in the evaluation of the relative efficiency of factor utilization domestically and internationally. Software metrics are used to characterize quantitatively. For small businesses, measuring productivity in terms of profit is often seen as the preferred method because its simple, and cuts right to the chase. Software productivity measurement using multiple size measures. This often leads to disappointment, because metrics only lead to positive change when theyre relevant, understood, and acted upon.
The software maintenance project effort estimation model based on. Designing a model for measuring manpower productivity in. Due to the critical lack of measurement methods, however, the magnitude of the productivity problem in the construction industry is largely unknown. The best metrics to measure the productivity of your software development are the metrics that you use to measure the business results. Total productivity output quantity and quality input quantity and quality. Maintenance metrics 101 for datadriven maintenance fiix. There are three main categories of maintenance metrics asset, operational, and inventory metrics. Metrics of software construction and maintenance can always be expressed as ratios between inputs and outputs of software. That said, there are some common measures that can be useful to consider to see if they apply to your situation. This paper will attempt to survey some current productivity measures for software.
Thats why the most widelyused maintenance metrics address the way equipment and people work. Maintenance productivity factor mpf is a metric that combines efficiency in execution, quality of maintenance work and the impact of organizational effectiveness to measure the productivity of the maintenance workforce. The questionnaire and delay survey process can be a. In addition to helping measure data acquisition efforts, this metrics also measures a maintenance teams degree of organization. It gained international momentum early on as customers across the us, spain, norway, italy and the netherlands began to use the solution to boost organisational productivity. Third, in contrast to much other research in this area, the intent is to examine the productivity of. Purpose the aim is to identify methods appropriate for measuring the direct productivity of facilities management fm in itselfproviders, on both the industry level and the firm level. They developed a complementary survey tool that is confidential. Pdf software productivity measurement using multiple size. Managing productivity employee surveys employee engagement. A systematic mapping on productivity metrics in software. This is especially true for software development organizations. Pdf factors affecting software maintenance productivity. Keywords software maintenance, productivity measures, s3m, maturity model 1.
Its important to measure, we all know that, but its imperative to measure the right things. For engineering teams, these metrics will empower you to measure effectiveness with the intent of improving productivity and driving peak performance. In terms of maintenance efficiency, the most suitable output measure is performance against a zerobased budget either in total costs or cost per unit of output, but there are other leading measures of maintenance efficiency that may be useful, such as. How to effectively define and measure maintainability. Software maintenance in software engineering is the modification of a software product after delivery to correct faults, to improve performance or other attributes a common perception of maintenance is that it merely involves fixing defects. Benchmarking guide for software development and maintenance projects. Measure and increase maintenance productivity with cmms. Measuring and improving software development productivity. Measuring maintenance effectiveness reliable plant.
Compare top facilities management software leaders selecthub how to improve your maintenance teams productivity 06. Indeed, the investment of time, human resources, and financial considerations associated with implementing cmms software is significant, so its only reasonable to expect returns in the form of increased efficiency. How to improve your maintenance teams productivity. Figure 3 shows that 77% of survey respondents saw some level of productivity enhancement as a result of their lean initiatives.
Service organizations, manufacturing, high tech, even nonprofit charities share the need to do more with less. Preventive maintenance software is one of the best tools for collecting accurate information from every asset, work order, and purchase. It represents the wealth created through the organisations production process or provision of services. So measuring productivity at your company by the amount of profit generated makes perfect sense. The productivity information can be used to adjust your budget, as new projects come into and leave the maintenance scope. For software estimation, typically two methods are used, expert judgment delphi method or scientific sizing method measure the size of software in terms of ifpug function points, cosmic function points and multiply by the organization specific productivity measures based on. In general, measure of productivity can be divided into multifactor productivity measures and singlefactor productivity measures. To conclude, some remarks are made regarding the application of productivity analysis for the software maintenance managers. How have software engineering researchers been measuring. Just because most organizations use a stat, it doesnt mean that itll make sense for your operation to use it too.
Software productivity measurement proceedings of the may 16. Measuring software design complexity,journal of systems and software 8, 3. Gps machine control technology aids productivity world. A guide to productivity measurement 7 value added is commonly used as a measure of output. In software development, 2 factors are used to measure productivity. Software metrics is a method to quantify attributes in software processes, products and projects. Measure and increase maintenance productivity with cmms software. Measuring the quality and productivity of software maintenance. Maintenance work sampling is simply a statistical tool that, when used effectively, can measure maintenance workforce productivity. Maintenance kpis maintenance metrics to measure performance. The first of these goals is to measure factors that production process input product affect software maintenance productivity, an issue sw development that has not been addressed in the mis literature.
Note that there are various methods to measure software size. Software maintenance productivity measurement software. Analyzing and improving productivity questionnaires and surveys. But today that isnt sufficientshipping software that works but doesnt create value is not a good measure. Labor productivity has a major impact on the cost of maintenance, and few maintenance managers know the effectiveness of their crews. Thomas has 40 years of refinery maintenance and reliability experience. Everything in maintenance revolves around humans and machines. This is the time it takes for the code to go from committing to deploy. A new productivity commission staff research note unpacks the concept of productivity and how it is measured. Measuring productivity in software development teams. Citeseerx citation query adm productivity measurement and.
The empirical analysis of a pilot data set indicated that high project quality did not necessarily reduce project productivity. How measuring maintenance productivity can identify. For electrical contractors that achieve a net income as low as 2% to 3%, a 5% to 10% improvement in labor productivity has the ability to double the bottom line. Companies routinely invest recruiting effort, manager time, hardware, software, salary, bonus, and a host of internal processes and programs to bring a new hire up to speed, yet rarely measure how long it takes to ramp up performance or productivity.
Throughout my career, i have seen or rather felt the various economic crises created by several factors, from the 1970s oil embargo to the world economic recession in 2008. No matter what kind of products or services your business offers, its important to measure employee productivity, and to measure it as accurately as possible. This paper will attempt to survey some current productivity measures for software development organizations and discuss their deficiencies. Ec1 the productivity metric was not explicitly defined or. Then a basic trend model is applied as well as ways to manage the expectations of the customers. In total, 91 software productivity metrics were extracted. Apr 18, 2020 in this article, we will reveal that measuring maintenance productivity is not a simple matter, and there is no single measure that can easily be applied. To that end, it is even more difficult to compare our data with our. Oct 31, 2014 the book improving software development productivity contains practices, models and case studies to quantitatively support adoption of agile software development.
Software maintenance productivity measurement amazon s3. Van wassenhove abstracttime is an essential measure of performance in software development because. Those measurements are then used to rate the individual or group performance. Choosing the right metrics that incentivize good habits and provide meaningful insight can be challenging. Mysammy employee productivity and performance measurement. It is quantitative relationship between what we produce and what we have spent to produce.
Maintenance productivity,ieee transactions on software engineering 17, 12. So often in practice, measurement in business means measures of partial productivity. Outputs typically consist of products or services or the value of these products or services, and inputs are the resources consumed or the cost of those resources. At the time, management experimented with the idea of allowing telecommuting employees to work from home through terminal server. Designing a model for measuring manpower productivity in the projectbased service organizations. Analyzing and improving productivity questionnaires and. Software maintenance productivity measurement iwsmmetrikon 2004 5 take over the responsibility of the software system to operate within the service levels agreed and established in the sla service level agreement. Most software development companies measure productivity of teams and individuals. The new software enhancements allow surveyors to collect, share and deliver data faster to improve accuracy, efficiency and productivity.
The first of these goals is to measure factors that affect software maintenance productivity, an issue. A large number of factors potentially affecting software maintenance productivity were included in this initial investigation. Although the construction industry is a major component of the u. Measuring the positioning of these points is typically used to establish maps and boundaries for buildings and other subterranean civic projects. How measuring maintenance productivity can identify significant costreduction opportunities. The top 8 methods for accurately measuring employee productivity. There are four eventual goals of our ongoing research. Measuring the productivity of facilities management. The office of personnel management opm, the independent agency of the united states federal government that manages the governments civilian workforce, uses a series of follow up emails and phone calls with both the employee and manager at two weeks, three months, and six months to assess timeto productivity over time. Sep 29, 2016 techniques for measurement of productivity 1. Some programs are elegant, some are exquisite, some are sparkling. Gps machine control boosts productivity world highways. The first of these goals is to measure factors that affect software.
Improving speed and productivity of software development. Machine control and gps specialist topcon believes that it has an edge over its competitors with its latest system, which will make a significant productivity boost for earthmoving applications. Jul 09, 2019 one of the biggest mistakes maintenance teams make is blindly adopting every measurement. Mysammy, llc pioneered the productivity measurement solution. Pdf software maintenance productivity and maturity researchgate. Software maintenance in software engineering is the modification of a software product after delivery to correct faults, to improve performance or other attributes. Productivity is a crucial concern for most organizations. This study could not have been done without the help of dhiya alshurougi. In addition, productivity factors on software maintenance projects should be. In this study, the software maintenance project effort estimation model.
333 863 603 1618 1572 89 1133 1050 1050 36 512 923 1172 269 268 1346 1218 1499 1111 254 601 1163 1612 343 1201 144 1405 44 1001 1316 172 269 1392 1389 703 908 859